Window replacement cost by frame material: what vinyl, wood, and fiberglass really add
Last updated November 19, 2026
This page may contain affiliate links. If you request quotes through them, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. How this works
Aluminum and vinyl cost the least, wood and fiberglass the most. But the gap is smaller than most price lists suggest. In a 2026 This Old House survey of 1,000 homeowners, the average price per installed window ran from $453 for aluminum to $564 for fiberglass. That is a difference of $111.
Prices by material
| Frame material | Published price range | Average paid in the survey |
|---|---|---|
| Aluminum | $200 to $800 | $453 |
| Vinyl | $350 to $800 | $472 |
| Composite | $300 to $2,500 | $513 |
| Wood | $600 to $2,000 | $544 |
| Fiberglass | $400 to $1,500 | $564 |
The ranges are installed prices per window from Fixr. The averages are what homeowners told This Old House they paid. The two sources measure different things, so read them side by side, not as one scale.
What the numbers say
Material moves the average by about a quarter. Fiberglass averaged $111 more per window than aluminum, and $92 more than vinyl. On ten windows, going from vinyl to fiberglass comes to roughly $920 at those averages.
The ranges overlap. A vinyl window at the top of its range costs $800. A fiberglass window at the bottom of its range costs $400. The material alone does not tell you which quote is higher.
So a large gap between two quotes is rarely the frame alone. Size, window type, glass, the installation method, and the floor the window is on all move the price. In the same survey, triple-pane glass averaged $609 per window, above every frame material.
What each material gives you
The U.S. Department of Energy compares frame materials by how well they hold heat and how much care they need.
- Aluminum. Strong, light, and almost maintenance-free. It conducts heat quickly, which makes it a poor insulator.
- Vinyl. Fixr calls it the standard frame material, a balance of price, durability, and insulation. It resists heat flow better than metal.
- Wood. Insulates relatively well and needs regular maintenance. Aluminum or vinyl cladding on the outside reduces the upkeep.
- Fiberglass. Stable in size, with air cavities that can be filled with insulation. The department rates its thermal performance above wood and uninsulated vinyl.
- Composite. Some composites resist heat flow better than metal. The price range is the widest of the five, so ask what the frame is made of.
On lifespan, This Old House gives 20 to 30 years for vinyl and 30 to 50 for fiberglass.
Check your quote
- Does the quote name the frame material and the product line? “Vinyl windows” covers an $800 window and a $350 one.
- If two quotes differ, is the material the same in both? If it is, the gap comes from something else. Ask what.
- Are you paying for a material your house needs? Better insulation matters more where heating or cooling bills are high.
Our window replacement cost calculator lets you switch the frame material and see how much of the total it changes in your state.
For the other things a quote can hide, see 6 costs a window replacement quote often leaves out and Insert or full-frame: which window replacement is your quote for?
The figures here are approximate ranges for planning, not an offer or professional advice. Your price depends on your home, your location, and the contractor.